The Battle of the BROW PENCILS


Hii my beauties 💋 💋 !!

Today is all about brow pencils! We all know and love brow pencils, because they are quite easy to use. But there are so many on the market that it gets hard to choose. On today’s post I will make it a bit easier for you guys. I will compare few of them and will let you know which one is my ultimate favorite one.


Brow pencil is a product that is applied to the eyebrow (of course), to shape and fill them, it comes in a pencil form (retractable or not).


For me, the perfect brow pencil is pigmented but not too pigmented, and the formula should be a bit dry, so the product doesn’t move around.

For every day I do prefer brow pencil over pomade, because it’s a quick and easy way to fill in those sparse areas in the brow.



I have tried quite a few brow pencils, and I do prefer some over others. But before I reveal which ones I do really like let me compare the performance of the ones I’ve tried.

ColourPop precision Brow Pencil Avon Brow Definer NYX Micro Brow Pencil Anastacia Beverly Hills Brow Definer Benefit Goof proof brow pencil

$ 5

$ 7 $ 10 $ 23

$ 24

Ammount of Product

0.09 gr

0.25 gr 0.89 gr 0.2 gr

0.34 gr


Jet Set Black

Soft Black Black Ebony

Shade no5


Micro Tip

Thick tip Micro Tip Triangular Tip

Triangular Tip


Creamy almost Satin

Creamy (a bit slippery) Satin Matte



Long Lasting

Long Lasting Long Lasting Long Lasting

Long Lasting


Too pigmented

Very pigmented Perfectly Pigmented 1 Perfectly Pigmented

Perfectly Pigmented


Easy but with a light hand

Harder to apply because the tip isn’t precise Easy to apply Easy to apply

Easy to apply


Plastic and retractable tube

Plastic and retractable tube Plastic and retractable tube Plastic and retractable tube

Plastic and retractable tube



No Yes Yes


1 When I say it’s perfectly pigmented I mean that it’s not too sheer nor too pigmented, the product makes applies in a way that it blends perfectly with the brow hairs.


So … drum roll please … my favorite one, from all these, for high end, is the Anastacia Beverly Hills Brow Definer, Anastacia truly is the brow queen, this brow pencil has the best perfect formula (but don’t like the spoolie that it comes with) and for drugstore I like the NYX Micro Brow Pencil (again, I don’t like the spoolie on this one).

My favorite spoolie is actually the one on the ColourPop Precision Brow Pencil, it’s the perfect size, thickness and the bristles are soft.

I hope this comparison review was helpful to you guys. If you have any questions feel free to leave them in the comment section below.


Hit the like button for more posts like this 👍.

Don’t forget to like, share and subscribe to my blog for more posts and videos 😀.

Blog footer

Instagram | Facebook | Bloglovin | Pinterest | Twitter | Snapchat (@Diicxita)

22 thoughts on “The Battle of the BROW PENCILS

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.